Dynasty Trade Value Chart: September

Dan Hindery's Dynasty Trade Value Chart: September Dan Hindery Published 09/01/2020

The 2020 season is almost here. As we find ourselves just over a week from kick-off, now is the time to put the finishing touches on our rosters as we try to go win our leagues. With trading action heating up, we will look at the biggest dynasty winners and losers from training camp. Moving quickly to take advantage of these changes in value can help you make winning trades if others are slower to adjust their preconceived notions of player values.

The dynasty trade value chart is tailored to 12-team PPR leagues a starting lineup of one quarterback, two running backs, three wide receivers, one tight end, and one flex. It now also includes trade values for Superflex leagues in a separate column. The chart is meant to serve primarily as a guide for trades but can also be a great resource during startup drafts. If the players and picks on each side of the trade offer add up to approximately the same number, the trade would be considered even. If you receive a trade offer that sends you players with a higher total number value than the players you are giving up, the offer is worth strongly considering. Each league is different, so pay close attention to the scoring and starting roster requirements specific to your league.

Quarterback

Pos Rank
Player
Superflex
Single-QB
1
64
30
2
58
28
3
45
18
4
42
17
5
40
16
6
36
11
7
32
10
8
28
9
9
28
9
10
26
7
11
25
7
12
21
7
13
20
6
14
19
6
15
18
5
16
18
4
17
18
4
18
17
4
19
17
4
20
17
4
21
16
4
22
16
4
23
15
4
24
14
4
25
13
3
26
12
3
27
12
3
28
12
3
29
10
1
30
7
2
31
7
2
32
7
1
33
6
1
34
Mitchell Trubisky
5
1
35
5
1
36
5
1
37
4
1
38
3
2
39
3
1
40
3
1

Winners

Joe Burrow
The way Burrow has won over his veteran teammates in less than a month on the field together has been pretty incredible. There is an “it” factor when it comes to Burrow that actually matters when it comes to the quarterback position. We have more evidence that Burrow is probably going to be a 15-year starter in the NFL. How many guys can you say that about with any confidence right now? Maybe five or six? Considering the value of having a locked-in long-term starter in Superflex leagues, Burrow should be viewed as a premium asset in that format. If you buy into reviews from teammates at all, it is easy to get excited about Burrow.

Tom Brady
The early returns on Brady in Tampa Bay have been extremely positive. There is clear QB1 upside in 2020 and Brady’s goal of playing into his mid-40s looks more realistic now than it did in the spring.

Losers

Tua Tagovailoa
Rookie quarterbacks struggle in camp all the time. It is not a major red flag that Tagovailoa is having problems. Still, the fact that he has not been able to separate from Josh Rosen in the battle for the backup spot is not encouraging. Nor are reports that Ryan Fitzpatrick looks significantly better.

Marcus Mariota
The contract Mariota received from the Raiders set up an expectation that he would push Derek Carr for the starting job this year and be well-positioned to take over in 2021. Instead, Carr has been infinitely better than Mariota in camp and Mariota is again nursing various injuries.

Running Back

Pos Rank
Player
Value
1
64
2
60
3
54
4
48
5
46
6
42
7
40
8
40
9
38
10
38
11
36
12
32
13
30
14
DAndre Swift
30
15
28
16
27
17
23
18
21
19
17
20
16
21
15
22
15
23
Melvin Gordon
14
24
14
25
13
26
13
27
13
28
A.J. Dillon
12
29
11
30
10
31
LeVeon Bell
10
32
10
33
9
34
9
35
9
36
KeShawn Vaughn
8
37
8
38
8
39
Mark Ingram
8
40
8
41
7
42
7
43
6
44
6
45
6
46
6
47
6
48
Benny Snell
6
49
6
50
Darrell Henderson
5
51
5
52
5
53
5
54
5
55
5
56
5
57
4
58
4
59
4
60
4
61
4
62
4
63
4
64
Lamical Perine
3
65
3
66
2
67
2
68
1
69
1

Winners

Clyde Edwards-Helaire
Good luck trying to trade for Edwards-Helaire if you did not draft him. His dynasty value before even taking an NFL snap is on the same level as that of Saquon Barkley and Ezekiel Elliott at the same point in their careers. Unlike those two, Edwards-Helaire does not come with an elite draft pedigree, which is an argument against getting this far out over our skis with him.

On the other hand, maybe the dynasty community has grown smarter since the days where you could steal elite rookies like Barkley and Elliott in the late 1st round of startups. NFL running backs enter their prime almost instantaneously, and that prime window usually only lasts five to seven years. Drafting a “proven” back who is already halfway through his prime over a rookie can end up being a disaster.

Here is a flashback to first-round ADPs at this time in 2017 with the rookie highlighted:

- Ezekiel Elliott (1.08)

Here is a flashback to first-round ADPs at this time in 2018 with the rookie highlighted:

- Saquon Barkley (1.07)

Life comes at you fast. So do swings in dynasty value. Try to get out ahead of things when you can.

Antonio Gibson
Gibson is the type of player who is easy to dream on given his size, speed, and receiving ability. Every time a Washington coach mentions Gibson in the same sentence as Christian McCaffrey, Gibson’s dynasty value increases a fraction. Remember that Gibson is far from a sure thing and could have minimal value in a year or two but it is okay to get excited about his upside. He is yet another player who was going in the second round of rookie drafts a few months ago who now carries first-round dynasty trade value.

Zack Moss
There were two competing viewpoints after the Bills drafted Moss in the third round. The first viewed him as a true backup to last year’s third-rounder Devin Singletary. The second viewpoint was that Moss would at least force his way into something like a 50/50 committee right away. Based on early reports, it looks like the second viewpoint was more accurate.

Damien Harris
Sony Michel’s absence through the first few weeks opened the door for Harris. He took full advantage and looks poised to at least force a timeshare in 2020. With Michel’s injury history, Harris has both short-term and long-term upside.

James Conner
There are fewer backs who are viewed as true workhorses in 2020 now than there were a month ago (see below). That makes Conner a more rare commodity. There are still plenty of questions beyond this season (Conner is set to hit free agency) but sometimes it is smarter to view running back through a short-term lens and take your production where you can find it.

The nice thing about Conner is that you can secure his backup Benny Snell for very little cost to protect against injury and give you some long-term upside if Conner is not brought back in 2021.

Losers

Leonard Fournette
The downfall of Fournette was both predictable and shocking to see actually play out. From 4th overall pick and a starring role in a deep playoff run in 2017 to street free agent a week before the 2020 season starts is a crazy fall. The going rate from what I have seen in my leagues right now is a 2021 2nd plus a small piece. It is hard to decide which side of these deals to like better.

KeShawn Vaughn
Ironically, Vaughn’s first camp is reminiscent of Ronald Jones II’ two years ago. Both saw their dynasty trade value drop before ever hitting the field. If Jones’ recent rise is any indication, perhaps patience is warranted for Vaughn. However, he is definitely worth less now than he was when he was in rookie drafts a few months ago.

Wide Receiver

Pos Rank
Player
Value
1
46
2
40
3
40
4
38
5
D.J. Moore
38
6
35
7
33
8
32
9
30
10
28
11
27
12
27
13
26
14
26
15
Odell Beckham
25
16
Allen Robinson
25
17
24
18
23
19
23
20
D.J. Chark
23
21
22
22
21
23
20
24
19
25
Henry Ruggs
19
26
18
27
18
28
17
29
16
30
16
31
16
32
15
33
14
34
14
35
14
36
14
37
14
38
14
39
13
40
Will Fuller
13
41
13
42
Laviska Shenault
13
43
13
44
12
45
Michael Pittman
12
46
Mecole Hardman
11
47
11
48
10
49
10
50
9
51
8
52
8
53
8
54
Marvin Jones
8
55
8
56
NKeal Harry
7
57
7
58
7
59
7
60
7
61
6
62
Robby Anderson
5
63
5
64
5
65
5
66
5
67
5
68
4
69
4
70
4
71
4
72
3
73
3
74
K.J. Hamler
3
75
3
76
2
77
2
78
2
79
2
80
2
81
2
82
2
83
2
84
2

Winners: Changing of the guard coming soon?

Can we just save time and say all of the rookie wide receivers were winners over the last month? Almost. Justin Jefferson, Tee Higgins, K.J. Hamler, and Denzel Mims have all missed time in camp and are off to relatively slow starts. But everyone else…

The top performers from the 2019 rookie class also continue to see their values rise, especially those who have been shining in camp. Over the last two years, we have had a major injection of young talent at the wide receiver position after what had been a few relatively lean years.

For a long time, the dynasty wide receiver ranks were dominated largely by the 2014 rookie class (Odell Beckham, Mike Evans, Davante Adams, Allen Robinson, Jarvis Landry, Brandin Cooks, etc.). Those players are now nearing the tail end of their prime years.

If these 21, 22, and 23-year olds from the last two rookie wide receiver classes continue to build on their hype, the Top 10 of the dynasty rankings at the position are going to look a lot different at this time next year.

Hyped rookies looking like the real deal

CeeDee Lamb
According to the writers at DallasCowboys.com, Lamb was voted the best receiver in camp. He “routinely turns out a highlight-reel catch and has the ability of doing it in a variety of ways.”

Jalen Reagor
The shoulder injury will slow Reagor’s rise temporarily but the camp reports were extremely positive before he got dinged up. Reagor looks like he is going to be Carson Wentz’s top receiver for the foreseeable future.

Henry Ruggs
Ruggs has been everything the Raiders thought he would be when they made him the top receiver drafted. His speed has opened eyes but also his leaping ability and general athleticism. The buzz for fellow rookie Bryan Edwards combined with skepticism over Derek Carr have kept Ruggs’ dynasty value from rising too much. In terms of bang for your buck, he may be the best rookie wide receiver trade target right now.

Jerry Jeudy
Unsurprisingly, Jeudy looks like an instant impact player for the Broncos. It is easy to envision Jeudy blowing away his current 11th round redraft ADP. If he does so, he will likely be a Top 10 dynasty wide receiver next offseason.

_

Less hyped rookies also looking like the real deal

We were banging the drum for stockpiling 2020 second-round picks for more than a year because of the depth of the wide receiver class. Anyone who planned ahead has to be feeling great about the strategy already given how well so many of these less hyped guys are already performing.

Brandon Aiyuk
Like Reagor, Aiyuk’s emergence has stalled with an injury. Unlike Reagor, Aiyuk’s mild hamstring strain is unlikely to keep him out of any regular-season action. Typically, minor camp injuries can derail entire rookie seasons but Aiyuk may be the exception.

Chase Claypool
Claypool’s monster camp seems to have flown under the radar for many dynasty managers. Perhaps because he did not receive as much hype in the pre-draft process and was a bit of an afterthought in most rookie drafts despite being drafted in the mid-second round by the Steelers. There may not be an easier bet to see a dynasty value increase over the next year. If Smith-Schuster hits free agency as expected, Claypool should be in the mix for the Steelers WR1 spot next summer.

Van Jefferson
The 2020 wide receiver class gets a lot of comparisons to the 2014 class. The comparison could be apt here because Jefferson could be this year’s Jarvis Landry. He has the second-round draft capital and is earning very strong reviews in camp but is not the exciting size-speed specimen many are looking to roster in dynasty. That could be a mistake here, especially if Cooper Kupp leaves as a free agent next spring.

Bryan Edwards
Edwards went in the third round of the NFL Draft but was going off the board ahead of many of the second-round receivers in rookie drafts. He is justifying that belief by starring early in camp. The shoulder injury to Tyrell Williams could open the door for Edwards to see more rookie snaps than he would have.

Young veterans standing out

DK Metcalf
Metcalf’s big rookie season looks like it was just the beginning. In terms of dynasty upside, few receivers can match Metcalf and the gushing reports from camp lend credence to the belief that Metcalf could be a Top 5 dynasty wide receiver in a month or two. If you are looking to get a bit younger, it is worth exploring whether you can still get Metcalf plus a good pick for somebody like DeAndre Hopkins or Photos provided by Imagn Images

Tags:
Dynasty Davante Adams Brandon Aiyuk Cam Akers Josh Allen Keenan Allen Robbie Chosen Mark Andrews J.J. Arcega-Whiteside Ryquell Armstead Devin Asiasi Saquon Barkley Odell Beckham Jr Le'Veon Bell Tyler Boyd Tom Brady Matt Breida Teddy Bridgewater A.J. Brown Antonio Brown John Brown Marquise Brown Joe Burrow Parris Campbell Derek Carr Chris Carson Quintez Cephus Nick Chubb D.J. Chark Jr Chase Claypool Randall Cobb Tevin Coleman James Conner Brandin Cooks Dalvin Cook Jared Cook Amari Cooper Kirk Cousins Jamison Crowder DeeJay Dallas Andy Dalton Sam Darnold Corey Davis Stefon Diggs AJ Dillon J.K. Dobbins Kenyan Drake Devin Duvernay Eric Ebron Chase Edmonds Bryan Edwards Clyde Edwards-Helaire Austin Ekeler Ezekiel Elliott Evan Engram Zach Ertz Darrynton Evans Mike Evans Noah Fant Ryan Fitzpatrick Nick Foles Leonard Fournette Devonta Freeman Will Fuller V Michael Gallup Antonio Gandy-Golden Jimmy Garoppolo Mike Gesicki Antonio Gibson Chris Godwin Dallas Goedert Jared Goff Kenny Golladay Melvin Gordon III A.J. Green Rob Gronkowski KJ Hamler Mecole Hardman Jr. Damien Harris N'Keal Harry Dwayne Haskins Darrell Henderson Jr. Derrick Henry Hunter Henry Justin Herbert Chris Herndon Tyler Higbee Tee Higgins Justice Hill Taysom Hill Tyreek Hill T.Y. Hilton Nyheim Hines T.J. Hockenson Austin Hooper DeAndre Hopkins Jordan Howard O.J. Howard Kareem Hunt Hayden Hurst Jalen Hurts Carlos Hyde Mark Ingram II DeSean Jackson Justin Jackson Lamar Jackson Josh Jacobs Blake Jarwin Justin Jefferson Van Jefferson Jerry Jeudy David Johnson Diontae Johnson Duke Johnson Jr Kerryon Johnson Aaron Jones Daniel Jones Julio Jones Marvin Jones Jr Ronald Jones II Alvin Kamara Travis Kelce Joshua Kelley Christian Kirk George Kittle Cole Kmet Dawson Knox Cooper Kupp CeeDee Lamb Jarvis Landry Allen Lazard Phillip Lindsay Drew Lock Tyler Lockett Jordan Love Marlon Mack Patrick Mahomes II Marcus Mariota Alexander Mattison Baker Mayfield Christian McCaffrey Jerick McKinnon Terry McLaurin DK Metcalf Sony Michel Anthony Miller Denzel Mims Gardner Minshew Joe Mixon David Montgomery DJ Moore Zack Moss Raheem Mostert Kyler Murray Latavius Murray Cam Newton David Njoku Devine Ozigbo DeVante Parker Rashaad Penny La'Mical Perine Breshad Perriman Adrian Peterson Michael Pittman Jr Tony Pollard Dak Prescott Jalen Reagor Hunter Renfrow Calvin Ridley Allen Robinson II Aaron Rodgers Ben Roethlisberger Josh Rosen John Ross Kyle Rudolph Henry Ruggs III Matt Ryan Curtis Samuel Deebo Samuel Emmanuel Sanders Miles Sanders Boston Scott Laviska Shenault Jr Sterling Shepard Steven Sims Jr Devin Singletary Darius Slayton Darius Slay Irv Smith Jr. Jonnu Smith JuJu Smith-Schuster Benny Snell Jr. Matthew Stafford Jace Sternberger Jarrett Stidham Courtland Sutton D'Andre Swift Tua Tagovailoa Ryan Tannehill Auden Tate Jonathan Taylor Adam Thielen Ian Thomas Michael Thomas Adam Trautman Mitch Trubisky C.J. Uzomah Ke'Shawn Vaughn Darren Waller James Washington Sammy Watkins Deshaun Watson Carson Wentz James White Darrel Williams Mike Williams Preston Williams Tyrell Williams Russell Wilson Jameis Winston Robert Woods

More by Dan Hindery

 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: May

Dan Hindery

Long-term player values for dynasty leagues

05/02/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: April

Dan Hindery

Long-Term Player Values for Dynasty Leagues

04/04/25 Read More
 

Stock Up, Stock Down: How the NFL Combine Moved Rookie ADP

Dan Hindery

Post-Combine ADP movement in Underdog Best Ball Drafts

03/10/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: March

Dan Hindery

Dynasty trade value can fluctuate; our Dan Hindery has this month's update for your dynasty leagues.

03/05/25 Read More
 

Underdog Pick Em: Super Bowl

Dan Hindery

Dan Hindery looks at the top Underdog Player Props to target in the Super Bowl

02/08/25 Read More
 

Dynasty Trade Value Chart: February

Dan Hindery

Analyzing Player Values for Dynasty Leagues

02/04/25 Read More