The Gut Check No. 632: The Consequences of Mobile QBs

The Gut Check examines the present and potential future consequences of mobile quarterbacks for the NFL and fantasy football.

Matt Waldman's The Gut Check No. 632: The Consequences of Mobile QBs Matt Waldman Published 10/02/2024

© Andrew Dieb-Imagn Images the gutcheck footballguys

The Konami Code Is Trashing the Passing Game

The age of the mobile quarterback is here. They're the fantasy Konami Code. Draft a quarterback who earns a ton of rushing yards and you have it made in your league. True story -- for now, at least. 

Yet, as more mobile quarterbacks enter the league and become franchise starters, there are signs that these players will limit the fantasy value of their teammates in the passing game. After studying five seasons of quarterback production, it's clear that the more a quarterback runs, the less likely he supports valuable fantasy talent in the passing game. 

Let's back up a bit. How should we define a mobile quarterback? Patrick Mahomes II, Josh Allen, Jalen Hurts, Lamar Jackson, Jayden Daniels, and Kyler Murray are mobile quarterbacks. However, it's how much the quarterback uses that mobility that matters. 

For this article, a quarterback who gains more than 19 percent of his yardage as a runner during a season was a running quarterback for that season. A quarterback who gains less than 20 percent of his yardage as a runner is a pocket quarterback. 

From 2020-2024, I examined 75 quarterback seasons and how many receivers and tight ends that these quarterbacks supported in the passing game. I also looked at this information through the lens of how much of that quarterback's yardage totals were with his legs. 

It's common sense that the higher the percentage of a quarterback's yardage comes on the ground, the less supportive he is to his teammates in the passing game. Still, I wanted to see where the volume of quarterback rushing yards produces diminishing returns for the passing game. 

Here are the values and totals of fantasy receivers quarterbacks have produced based on the percent of yardage they earned in a season with their legs. The information is based on a 12-team PPR format. Although I've listed each value as "WR," I included tight ends and assigned them the equivalent WR value. 

As you can see, the less a QB ran the better his receivers' fantasy production.

Fantasy Value of Supporting Cast Based on QB Rushing Production

Pct RunQBWR1WR2WR3WR4WR5Total
0-4%252717681194
5-9%251912128783
10-14%84411725
15-19%106445635
20-24%42111211
25+%4000318

I also counted how many fantasy receivers each quarterback supported in a season based on the percentage of his yards coming as a runner. Again, I included the top 60 fantasy receivers (WR1s-WR5s) in a 12-team PPR format. As you can see the quarterbacks who ran the least, generated the most receivers with fantasy value. 

The Number of Fantasy Receivers Supported In A Season By QBs Based on Rush Yardage Pcts. 

Pct Run01234
0-4%018105
5-9%0311101
10-14%01601
15-19%01423
20-24%01110
25+%11100

Go ahead, pick the running quarterback, but you better pick the receivers who have a pocket quarterback throwing to them. 

Are Mobile QBs Hurting Passing Offenses?

To a degree they are. Let's clarify this statement though. There are quarterbacks with elite running talent who also can win from the pocket and support fantasy talent in the passing game. 

The problem isn't the type of quarterback entering the NFL, but the desire for NFL owners to force-feed these players into starting lineups. Coaches hate playing rookie quarterbacks, but the pressure for them to comply is enormous and they know if they don't win immediately AND win with the rookie quarterback, they will be fired before that quarterback can develop into a complete passer. 

The best solution thus far has been to simplify the offense and use a scheme that meets the quarterback with where he is and not stretch him to where he'll need to be. This means limiting their ability to adjust plays and make a high volume of progression reasons where they have a role in choosing the receiver and manipulating the coverage. 

Instead, the scheme relies on more schemed plays with limited reads, if there is even more than one read. There are also fewer passes down the field. 

It can generate early success but it's often an inflated result. Defenses eventually compile their scouting reports into game plans that can limit these quarterbacks.

Coaches with these quarterbacks are hoping they can slow-launch their young passer and gradually expand the number of reads they make as defenses catch on. However, this is a gamble that doesn't always pay off because the quarterback isn't ready for those demands. 

The more coaches that are doing this with young quarterbacks so they can win enough games to keep their jobs are now stuck in situations where the quality of quarterback play is lower across the league. As ESPN showed on Tuesday with a terrific piece on the massive decline of passing in the league this year, the caliber of quarterback play is a reason coaches are citing as a significant factor. 

If this QB development strategy continues, we could approach a point where passing remains down and the intent of delivering "exciting QB-centric football" backfires. Based on the steady decrease in yards per game between 2016 to 2014 from 250.9 to 202.8 -- and a significant three-year dip coinciding with more umbrella coverages -- this is coinciding with a change in defensive coverages to confuse the number of starters in the league who are less experience than ever. 

Again, this isn't to say that running quarterbacks are the problem. Jalen Hurts has had seasons as a running quarterback and a pocket quarterback. He has been better as a pocket quarterback. It's about striking the right balance, but that balance comes from development, which is incumbent on both the player and the team willing to exhibit patience. 

Many of these quarterbacks can become excellent pocket passers and field generals with reading coverage. It's whether the NFL will do what it takes to support that growth.  

Fantasy Advice for the Near Future

If a quarterback entering the league is known as a runner, it may be worth drafting them but avoiding their receiving talent until you have a year to assess how their new team will use them. At best, expect no better than WR3 value from that quarterback's best receiver. 

Here are the charts from the past five years that show the top 15 quarterbacks, their percentage of yardage as a runner, and the ranking of their top three receivers and top tight end. The tight end column has the player's rank and his relative rank with receivers (in parenthesis). If these columns are blank, it means there was no one of significant value to list. 

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Tennessee.

The columns to the right are the count of the type of fantasy value the quarterback supported that year--how many WR1s (top-12), WR2s (13th-24th), etc. 

QB2020Pct RunWRWRWRTEWR1WR2WR3WR4WR5Total
1Josh Allen8%33260 101013
2Patrick Mahomes II6%271981 (3)200002
3Kyler Murray17%555128 100001
4Aaron Rodgers3%159758 (59)100001
5Deshaun Watson8%91847 110002
6Russell Wilson11%81591 110002
7Lamar Jackson27%42951364 (45)000202
8Justin Herbert5%65710111 (66)100012
9Tom Brady0%13172316030003
10Ryan Tannehill7%377815321000101
11Kirk Cousins4%101112525200002
12Gardner Minshew II6%444965 000112
13Joe Burrow5%3740  000202
14Derek Carr3%4577 2 (8)100102
15Matt Ryan2%4144917110013

 

QB2021Pct RunWRWRWRTEWR1WR2WR3WR4WR5Total
1Josh Allen15%1050559 (52)100034
2Tom Brady2%68113 (28)301004
3Justin Herbert6%1217  110002
4Patrick Mahomes II7%766812 (13)200002
5Kyler Murray10%20345110 (55)011024
6Aaron Rodgers2%25475 100012
7Jalen Hurts20%4247 8 (50)000213
8Dak Prescott3%2129 5 (40)011103
9Lamar Jackson21%2264 1 (9)110002
10Joe Burrow2%51338 200103
11Matthew Stafford1%11949 120003
12Kirk Cousins3%41656 110013
13Russell Wilson6%1823  020002
14Jameis Winston12%60627712000011
15Ryan Tannehill7%2775  001001

 

QB2022Pct RunWRWRWRTEWR1WR2WR3WR4WR5Total
1Jalen Hurts17%715 5 (37)120104
2Patrick Mahomes II6%3334 1 (7)102003
3Josh Allen15%6385113110103
4Joe Burrow5%3295020111014
5Justin Fields32%64  15000000
6Lamar Jackson25%5670 3 (34)001012
7Geno Smith8%1422  020002
8Daniel Jones18%395763 000112
9Trevor Lawrence7%1932 7 (54)011013
10Kyler Murray15%928416 (46)101204
11Tua Tagovailoa2%413  111014
12Kirk Cousins2%247584 (35)101114
13Jared Goff2%1160  100012
14Justin Herbert3%12234517110103
15Dak Prescott6%8  9100001

 

QB2023Pct RunWRWRWRTEWR1WR2WR3WR4WR5Total
1Josh Allen11%14527413 (65)100012
2Jalen Hurts14%720 12 (62)110002
3Lamar Jackson18%3466805 (29)002002
4Dak Prescott5%1469210 (56)100113
5Kirk Cousins1%531702 (21)111003
6Jordan Love6%274347 001203
7Brock Purdy3%1315 6 (42)020103
8C.J. Stroud4%8194811 (59)110114
9Justin Fields20%991 8 (54)100012
10Kyler Murray12%5177 9 (55)000022
11Justin Herbert7%31044 200103
12Patrick Mahomes II9%28841011 (20)011002
13Russell Wilson10%385688 000112
14Jared Goff0%469754 (27)101002
15Trevor Lawrence8%2932613 (26)003003

 

QB2024Pct RunWRWRWRTEWR1WR2WR3WR4WR5Total
1Lamar Jackson26%47681068 (65)000101
2Jayden Daniels20%31738413 (77)001001
3Baker Mayfield6%7208819 (96)110002
4Jordan Love1%6576911 (76)100012
5Josh Allen12%287410310 (75)110002
6Sam Darnold5%4195029210003
7Justin Fields15%36751137 (59)001012
8Jalen Hurts15%112872 (28)201003
9Dak Prescott2%1458775 (51)010012
10Kyler Murray17%1660704 (50)010012
11Joe Burrow4%13485414 (78)010113
12Brock Purdy6%817672 (21)120003
13Geno Smith6%9345323101013
14C.J. Stroud4%3116628200002
15Jared Goff2%10239817 (90)110002

This summer, my draft strategies recommended the old-school RB beginning. At the rate impatient and impulsive NFL owners are force-feeding mobile quarterbacks into lineups, we'll be going back to the future once again in 2025. 

Good luck!

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images

More by Matt Waldman

 

Replacements: Week 18

Matt Waldman

The weekly list of preemptive additions before their fantasy emergence and candidates who could contribute due to unexpected late-week events.

01/03/25 Read More
 

Replacements: Week 17

Matt Waldman

The weekly list of preemptive additions before their fantasy emergence and candidates who could contribute due to unexpected late-week events.

12/27/24 Read More
 

The Gut Check No.644: What We Got from Michael Penix Jr.

Matt Waldman

Matt Waldman breaks down what fantasy GMs got from quarterback Michael Penix Jr.'s first start and what to expect moving forward.

12/24/24 Read More
 

The Top 10: Week 17 (Lessons Learned and Validated)

Matt Waldman

The Top 10 features Matt Waldman's film-driven analysis to help GMs manage their fantasy squads.

12/24/24 Read More
 

Replacements: Week 16

Matt Waldman

The weekly list of preemptive additions before their fantasy emergence and candidates who could contribute due to unexpected late-week events.

12/20/24 Read More
 

Roundtable: Fantasy vs. Reality II

Matt Waldman

The Footballguys roundtable picks between sets of two players they'd prefer in fantasy football and building an NFL team.

12/19/24 Read More