Chance to Play: Questionable vs. Doubtful

Our Adam Hutchison examines how the injury report designation affects a player's chance to play that week.

Adam Hutchison's Chance to Play: Questionable vs. Doubtful Adam Hutchison Published 09/01/2024

The Footballguys Injury Index contains injury timelines and fantasy performance outcomes specifically for quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers, and tight ends from 2017-2023. Altogether, there are over 2,000 injuries in the database. However, to avoid any confusion, it is important to lay some ground rules. I am not saying that this is exactly what will happen. I do not have a crystal ball, nor should this report be used as one. Like most things in life, context is important. Every injury is unique.

Enjoy.

Sections of the Footballguys Injury Index

Chance to Play, Questionable vs. Doubtful
Chance to Play, Practice Participation
Games Played and Positional Volatility
Fantasy Performance and Re-Injury Rate by Position

Questionable vs. Doubtful

Per the NFL rules, when a player is listed as Questionable (Q), there is uncertainty if that player will play that week, while the Doubtful (D) tag means a player is unlikely to be available. In short, questionable should mean that a player is truly 50/50 that week, and doubtful implies the chances are slim.

The numbers do not necessarily reflect that, as some NFL teams do not use the Questionable tag correctly. Doubtful was more straightforward.

Listed as Questionable on Team's Final Injury Report

  • 71% of players ended up playing
  • 29% of players did not play

Listed as Doubtful on Team's Final Injury Report

  • 94.1% of players did not play
  • 5.9% of players end up playing

Team Tendencies

Here are the specific tendencies when an NFL team lists a quarterback, running back, wide receiver, or tight end as Questionable or Doubtful on the final injury report. Teams like Tampa Bay and Chicago tend to be more liberal with the Questionable designation. Conversely, when a player is listed as Questionable on Philadelphia's final injury report, their chances of playing are much slimmer.

Doubtful designations are much more straightforward. Only four teams even allowed a player to player after being tabbed as Doubtful.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a PRO subscription.

TeamQuestionable % Chance to PlayDoubtful % Chance to Play
Arizona65.790
Atlanta50.000
Baltimore75.290
Buffalo52.270
Carolina84.210
Chicago86.670
Cincinnati78.120
Cleveland77.780
Dallas63.160
Denver80.770
Detroit80.880
Green Bay66.679
Houston48.440
Indianapolis83.930
Jacksonville73.210
Kansas City64.520
LA Chargers81.130
LA Rams63.640
Las Vegas72.500
Miami63.380
Minnesota58.060
New England74.140
New Orleans51.220
NY Giants85.7114
NY Jets80.495
Philadelphia28.000
Pittsburgh68.750
San Francisco74.4714
Seattle68.090
Tampa Bay90.910
Tennessee63.640
Washington76.920

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images

More by Adam Hutchison

 

3 Injuries to Watch for in 2025

Adam Hutchison

Our Injury Expert Adam Hutchison, examines player injuries from 2024 that could affect their 2025 season.

02/10/25 Read More
 

The Top 5 Players Who Might Not Be Ready for Week 1

Adam Hutchison

Our Injury Expert Adam Hutchison, examines player injuries from 2024 that could affect their 2025 season.

01/27/25 Read More
 

Injury Roundup From the NFL's Divisional Round

Adam Hutchison

A Monday morning recap of the fantasy football relevant injuries from the NFL's Divisional Round by our Injury Expert Adam Hutchison

01/20/25 Read More
 

Injury Roundup From Wild Card Weekend

Adam Hutchison

A Tuesday morning recap of the fantasy football relevant injuries from the NFL's Wild Card Weekend by our Injury Expert Adam Hutchison

01/14/25 Read More
 

Injury Roundup From Week 18

Adam Hutchison

A Monday morning recap of the fantasy football relevant injuries from Week 18 of the NFL season by our Injury Expert Adam Hutchison

01/06/25 Read More
 

Gameday Injury Expectations: Week 18

Adam Hutchison

This article summarizes all the injuries before Week 18 with a breakdown of fantasy production post-injury along with how likely a player is to start following their injury.

01/04/25 Read More