The following feature is a free preview of our content. If you like it, click here to sign up for access to our Footballguys Subscription, and you'll get all of our content. We're so confident you'll love it that we offer an industry-leading 30-day Money-Back Guarantee, ensuring zero risk.
RELATED: See More Like This here.
As we race toward August, Footballguys.com will examine one team per weekday with our quick-hitting Team Vibes feature, which explores the overall mood toward each team's offense.
Go Deeper: See in-depth projections for every Giants player here.
Looking for IDP? Dive into what the Eyes of the Guru see here.
New York is coming off a season where pretty much everything not named Malik Nabers went wrong. What's the vibe for 2025?
Spoiler alert: Mostly meh.
Giants, Team Vibes
- Good - 1 vote
- Neutral - 9 votes
- Bad - 4 votes
Staffers with Good Vibes
- Phil Alexander: Relatively speaking, of course. With actual professionals in the quarterback room, it’s hard to do worse than last season’s 16.1 points per game.
Staffers with Neutral Vibes
- Jason Wood: Things can't get much worse for the Giants, and everyone from GM Schoen to Coach Daboll understands their jobs are on thin ice.
- Kyle Bellefeuil: The Giants have a more competent quarterback room entering this season, but we’ll need to see progress before moving the needle too far.
- Maurile Tremblay: Wilson steadies the QB spot, and Nabers is elite; but a patched?up O-line and untested RB room keep the ceiling in check.
- Jeff Haseley: The Giants are on the verge of turning the corner, but they have a giant question mark at quarterback. The offense and likely the Giants' outlook hinge on the success or struggles at quarterback.
- Julia Papworth: The Giants head into 2025 with a more concrete plan at quarterback (maybe?), at least we think they do, signing Russell Wilson and drafting Jaxson Dart.
- Craig Lakins: The quarterback position is a big question mark, but Malik Nabers is all set for another massive season.
- Hutchinson Brown: The general manager and head coach are on the hot seat, and the quarterback spot is not yet fixed.
- Jeff Bell: The Giants have locked in young blue-chip players at the key positions of pass rusher, wide receiver, and left tackle, but their regime faces a make-or-break year.
- Ben Cummins: First-round quarterback Jaxson Dart provides hope to an offense surrounded by good young NFL talent in Malik Nabers, Darius Slayton, Wan'Dale Robinson, Theo Johnson, Tyrone Tracy Jr., and Cam Skattebo.
Staffers with Bad Vibes
- Tripp Brebner: Has there been less excitement for a team with a Day-1 rookie QB AND the #3 overall pick?
- David Zacharias: The Giants have the most difficult schedule, and Russell Wilson is cooked.
- Jeff Blaylock: Following a trainwreck of a season, the Giants enter 2025 among the worst odds to win the Super Bowl. Coach Brian Daboll, who is 9-25 over the past two seasons, is a dead man walking.
- Andy Hicks: There is no middle ground here. Either the Giants' patience with Brian Daboll pays off, or they start again in 2026. The signs are not good.