3 Offensive Lines That Might Be Overrated

Offensive line expert Matt Bitonti looks at three offensive lines that could disappoint in 2024.

Matt Bitonti's 3 Offensive Lines That Might Be Overrated Matt Bitonti Published 08/28/2024

You've likely seen our official Footballguys Offensive Line rankings. A ton of research goes into them, and I stand by them. The model used to create those rankings has been around for several years. It is solid.

At the same time, just as with fantasy rankings at other positions, some lines could be better or worse or all over the place.

RELATED: See Underrated Offensive Lines here >>>
RELATED: See Hard-to-Rank Offensive Lines here >>>

Let's look at three offensive lines that could be overrated.

Overrated OL: Cleveland

PosStarterCurrent Rankings
LTJedrick Wills6th overall
LGJoel Bitonio4th in run blocking
CEthan Pocic11th in pass blocking
RGWyatt Teller 
RTDawand Jones 

All-Pro LG Joel Bitonio and RG Wyatt Teller are great. And this line has been good for a while. But it could be due for a correction. Legendary offensive line coach Bill Callahan has departed for Tennessee. Starting tackles LT Jedrick Wills (knee) and RT Jack Conklin (knee) can't get off PUP. James Hudson (ankle) has been spotty in relief. RT Dewand Jones is good, but LT is a real question heading into the season. In depth news, backup center Luke Wypler broke his leg, causing the team to trade a pick to Seattle for Nick Harris.  

Overrated OL: Cincinnati

PosStarterCurrent Rankings
LTOrlando Brown8th overall
LGCordell Volson9th in run blocking
CTed Karras19th in pass blocking
RGAlex Cappa 
RTTrent Brown 

The tackle duo of LT Orlando Brown (4x Pro Bowl) and RT Trent Brown (1x Pro Bowl) is excellent on paper. But with rookie Amarius Mims (round 1 – Georgia) out several weeks with a strained pectoral (chest), the spotlight is firmly on Brown, who has only finished a complete regular season twice in his 9-year career. Cody Ford is a versatile backup but not an ideal fit at RT. Brown will be healthy and extra motivated to face his former team, New England, in the season opener, but I'll feel better about the Bengals' top-10 ranking when Mims gets healthy.

Overrated OL: LA Rams

PosStarterCurrent Rankings
LTAleric Jackson18th overall
LGJonah Jackson12th in run blocking
CSteve Avila10th in pass blocking
RGKevin Dotson 
RTRob Havenstein 

In an ideal world with everyone healthy and available, this mid-teen ranking would be fair, maybe even a little low. But starting LT Alaric Jackson is suspended two games for conduct and RT Rob Havenstein is week-to-week with an ankle injury. Joe Noteboom will start two games for Jackson, but there's no definitive word on Havenstein. New LG Jonah Jackson (Detroit) has been out several weeks with an ankle injury of his own, but he rejoined practice and should be on track to start the season. Still, there's just a lot of uncertainty around this Rams' group at the moment.

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images
Share This Article

Featured Articles

 

9 Deep Dynasty Sleepers To Pick Up

Rachel Tootsiepop

Wood, Bloom, Kantzabedian, Kashuba, Blaylock, Zacharias, Hicks, Tootsiepop, and Papworth discuss deep dynasty sleepers.

03/26/25 Read More
 
 
 
 

More by Matt Bitonti

 

2025 NFL Mock Draft from Matt Bitonti 2.0

Matt Bitonti

2025 NFL mock draft: Matt Bitonti releases his second projection of the season.

03/24/25 Read More
 

2025 NFL Mock Draft from Matt Bitonti

Matt Bitonti

2025 NFL mock draft: Matt Bitonti releases his first projection of the season.

03/04/25 Read More
 

Offensive Line Rankings

Matt Bitonti

Our Matt Bitonti with Injury News and Lineup Changes for all 32 NFL Offensive Lines.

01/18/25 Read More
 

3 Offensive Lines That Might Be Overrated

Matt Bitonti

Offensive line expert Matt Bitonti looks at three offensive lines that could disappoint in 2024.

08/28/24 Read More
 

3 Offensive Lines That Might Be Underrated

Matt Bitonti

Offensive line expert Matt Bitonti looks at three offensive lines that could surprise in 2024.

08/28/24 Read More
 

3 Offensive Lines That Are Boom or Bust

Matt Bitonti

Offensive line expert Matt Bitonti looks at three offensive lines that are wild cards for the 2024 season.

08/28/24 Read More