Defensive Team By Committee (DTBC)

Our Clayton Gray looks at a common strategy used at the team defense position.

Clayton Gray's Defensive Team By Committee (DTBC) Clayton Gray Published 09/03/2024

There are a couple of common approaches to addressing the team defense position in fantasy drafts.

  • Draft a top defense fairly early.
  • Draft two defenses fairly late to stream your way to production that is on par with a top defense.

Well, there is another common approach. Draft a decent defense, drop it when it underproduces, pick up another one, drop it, and rinse and repeat all season long.

Let's avoid that third approach.

Going After a Top Defense

Simply put, you're in the wrong place for a top defense. But if that's how you roll, we have multiple avenues for you to take here.

  • Use the Draft Dominator. With it, you'll be able to get fully customized rankings. You'll know exactly which top defense you should target.

  • Go straight to our Defensive Team rankings. These are customizable, but the generic list will give you a general feel for highly rated defenses.

If you're having trouble deciding on a top defense or you want one with an easy schedule, take a moment to check out our SOS for defenses.

Now, let's find a DTBC.

Starting-Level Defenses

If we have a DTBC, we won't be taking an early defense. And that means we won't start the season with a single starting-level defense (here are the first 12 defenses off the board, listed with their projected fantasy points per game).

  • Dallas Cowboys - 16.27
  • Baltimore Ravens - 16.24
  • Cleveland Browns - 16.09
  • San Francisco 49ers - 16.19
  • New York Jets - 16.07
  • Buffalo Bills - 16.03
  • Kansas City Chiefs - 15.72
  • Pittsburgh Steelers - 15.92
  • Chicago Bears - 15.5
  • Houston Texans - 15.7
  • Miami Dolphins - 15.82
  • Cincinnati Bengals - 15.5

Matching the Bills

The goal of creating a DTBC is to compete against starting-level defenses. But if we just want to get into the top 12, we can just take the Cincinnati defense. Instead of just getting by, let's compete toward the top and be in the top half of a 12-team league. So, to get a top-6 defense, we need to beat the Bills and average over 16 fantasy points per game.

Without taking any of the 12 defenses listed above, let's find 16.03 PPG and beat the Bills.

Finding DTBCs

Finding the right committee will be based on three things:

  • Bye-week compatibility - This seems obvious, but your two defenses can't have the same bye.
  • Projected fantasy points scored - Defenses projected to score more fantasy points this season will generally rank higher in the list of possible committees.
  • Strength of schedule - Defenses with easier opponents will generally rank higher in the list of possible committees.

So let's get to it.

Looking through the 165 possibilities, a whopping 128 of them are projected to beat the Bills. And 113 of them are projected to beat the Cowboys.

Yes, tons of quality options with a good deal of variety. Take a look.

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a 100% FREE Insider account.

By signing up and providing us with your email address, you're agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive emails from Tennessee.
RankTeam 1Team 2FPs/Game
1Philadelphia EaglesTampa Bay Buccaneers18.0
2Philadelphia EaglesNew York Giants17.9
3Philadelphia EaglesNew Orleans Saints17.8
4Philadelphia EaglesJacksonville Jaguars17.7
5Tampa Bay BuccaneersNew Orleans Saints17.7
6New Orleans SaintsDenver Broncos17.7
7New Orleans SaintsIndianapolis Colts17.6
8Philadelphia EaglesMinnesota Vikings17.5
9Philadelphia EaglesDenver Broncos17.5
10New York GiantsDenver Broncos17.5
11Seattle SeahawksNew Orleans Saints17.4
12New York GiantsNew Orleans Saints17.4
13New York GiantsIndianapolis Colts17.4
14Philadelphia EaglesIndianapolis Colts17.3
15Philadelphia EaglesNew England Patriots17.3
16Philadelphia EaglesWashington Commanders17.3
17Arizona CardinalsNew Orleans Saints17.3
18New Orleans SaintsNew England Patriots17.3
19Philadelphia EaglesSeattle Seahawks17.2
20Tennessee TitansNew Orleans Saints17.2
21Tampa Bay BuccaneersIndianapolis Colts17.2
22Jacksonville JaguarsIndianapolis Colts17.2
23Jacksonville JaguarsDenver Broncos17.2
24Philadelphia EaglesGreen Bay Packers17.1
25Philadelphia EaglesLas Vegas Raiders17.1
26Los Angeles RamsNew Orleans Saints17.1
27Minnesota VikingsNew York Giants17.1
28Minnesota VikingsTampa Bay Buccaneers17.1
29Las Vegas RaidersNew Orleans Saints17.1
30Carolina PanthersNew Orleans Saints17.1
31New York GiantsJacksonville Jaguars17.1
32Tampa Bay BuccaneersJacksonville Jaguars17.1
33Philadelphia EaglesCarolina Panthers17.0
34Philadelphia EaglesAtlanta Falcons17.0
35Detroit LionsNew Orleans Saints17.0
36Minnesota VikingsNew Orleans Saints17.0
37Minnesota VikingsAtlanta Falcons17.0
38Arizona CardinalsJacksonville Jaguars17.0
39New York GiantsAtlanta Falcons17.0
40Tampa Bay BuccaneersDenver Broncos17.0
41Tampa Bay BuccaneersNew England Patriots17.0
42New Orleans SaintsWashington Commanders17.0
43Atlanta FalconsIndianapolis Colts17.0
44Jacksonville JaguarsNew England Patriots17.0
45Philadelphia EaglesLos Angeles Rams16.9
46Detroit LionsNew York Giants16.9
47Los Angeles ChargersNew Orleans Saints16.9
48Tennessee TitansNew York Giants16.9
49Tennessee TitansIndianapolis Colts16.9
50Minnesota VikingsJacksonville Jaguars16.9
51Green Bay PackersTampa Bay Buccaneers16.9
52Las Vegas RaidersTampa Bay Buccaneers16.9
53Tampa Bay BuccaneersWashington Commanders16.9
54Los Angeles ChargersTampa Bay Buccaneers16.8
55Minnesota VikingsGreen Bay Packers16.8
56Green Bay PackersNew York Giants16.8
57Green Bay PackersNew Orleans Saints16.8
58Las Vegas RaidersJacksonville Jaguars16.8
59Seattle SeahawksJacksonville Jaguars16.8
60New York GiantsNew England Patriots16.8
61Tampa Bay BuccaneersAtlanta Falcons16.8
62Los Angeles ChargersIndianapolis Colts16.7
63Green Bay PackersIndianapolis Colts16.7
64Las Vegas RaidersNew York Giants16.7
65Las Vegas RaidersDenver Broncos16.7
66Seattle SeahawksNew York Giants16.7
67Seattle SeahawksTampa Bay Buccaneers16.7
68Arizona CardinalsIndianapolis Colts16.7
69Carolina PanthersJacksonville Jaguars16.7
70Atlanta FalconsDenver Broncos16.7
71Jacksonville JaguarsWashington Commanders16.7
72Philadelphia EaglesArizona Cardinals16.6
73Detroit LionsTampa Bay Buccaneers16.6
74Detroit LionsJacksonville Jaguars16.6
75Tennessee TitansMinnesota Vikings16.6
76Tennessee TitansTampa Bay Buccaneers16.6
77Los Angeles RamsJacksonville Jaguars16.6
78Los Angeles RamsIndianapolis Colts16.6
79Minnesota VikingsIndianapolis Colts16.6
80Green Bay PackersJacksonville Jaguars16.6
81Green Bay PackersDenver Broncos16.6
82New York GiantsWashington Commanders16.6
83Atlanta FalconsNew England Patriots16.6
84Los Angeles ChargersAtlanta Falcons16.5
85Los Angeles ChargersJacksonville Jaguars16.5
86Tennessee TitansJacksonville Jaguars16.5
87Los Angeles RamsNew York Giants16.5
88Los Angeles RamsTampa Bay Buccaneers16.5
89Minnesota VikingsDenver Broncos16.5
90Las Vegas RaidersIndianapolis Colts16.5
91Seattle SeahawksIndianapolis Colts16.5
92Carolina PanthersAtlanta Falcons16.5
93Atlanta FalconsWashington Commanders16.5
94Minnesota VikingsLas Vegas Raiders16.4
95Minnesota VikingsSeattle Seahawks16.4
96Minnesota VikingsArizona Cardinals16.4
97Green Bay PackersNew England Patriots16.4
98Las Vegas RaidersAtlanta Falcons16.4
99Las Vegas RaidersNew England Patriots16.4
100Carolina PanthersDenver Broncos16.4
101Detroit LionsIndianapolis Colts16.3
102Los Angeles ChargersMinnesota Vikings16.3
103Los Angeles ChargersGreen Bay Packers16.3
104Los Angeles ChargersSeattle Seahawks16.3
105Los Angeles ChargersDenver Broncos16.3
106Tennessee TitansDenver Broncos16.3
107Tennessee TitansNew England Patriots16.3
108Tennessee TitansWashington Commanders16.3
109Minnesota VikingsWashington Commanders16.3
110Green Bay PackersCarolina Panthers16.3
111Green Bay PackersAtlanta Falcons16.3
112Las Vegas RaidersWashington Commanders16.3
113Carolina PanthersIndianapolis Colts16.3
114Los Angeles ChargersLas Vegas Raiders16.2
115Los Angeles ChargersNew York Giants16.2
116Tennessee TitansCarolina Panthers16.2
117Minnesota VikingsNew England Patriots16.2
118Seattle SeahawksAtlanta Falcons16.2
119Seattle SeahawksDenver Broncos16.2
120Arizona CardinalsDenver Broncos16.2
121Detroit LionsMinnesota Vikings16.1
122Detroit LionsAtlanta Falcons16.1
123Tennessee TitansSeattle Seahawks16.1
124Tennessee TitansAtlanta Falcons16.1
125Green Bay PackersWashington Commanders16.1
126Las Vegas RaidersCarolina Panthers16.1
127Seattle SeahawksNew England Patriots16.1
128Arizona CardinalsWashington Commanders16.1
129Los Angeles ChargersNew England Patriots16.0
130Tennessee TitansGreen Bay Packers16.0
131Los Angeles RamsGreen Bay Packers16.0
132Los Angeles RamsAtlanta Falcons16.0
133Green Bay PackersArizona Cardinals16.0
134Las Vegas RaidersArizona Cardinals16.0
135Arizona CardinalsAtlanta Falcons16.0
136Arizona CardinalsNew England Patriots16.0
137Detroit LionsLas Vegas Raiders15.9
138Tennessee TitansLas Vegas Raiders15.9
139Los Angeles RamsNew England Patriots15.9
140Minnesota VikingsCarolina Panthers15.9
141Seattle SeahawksCarolina Panthers15.9
142Seattle SeahawksWashington Commanders15.9
143Detroit LionsGreen Bay Packers15.8
144Detroit LionsSeattle Seahawks15.8
145Detroit LionsCarolina Panthers15.8
146Detroit LionsDenver Broncos15.8
147Detroit LionsNew England Patriots15.8
148Detroit LionsWashington Commanders15.8
149Tennessee TitansArizona Cardinals15.8
150Los Angeles RamsDenver Broncos15.8
151Los Angeles RamsWashington Commanders15.8
152Carolina PanthersNew England Patriots15.8
153Los Angeles RamsLas Vegas Raiders15.7
154Seattle SeahawksArizona Cardinals15.7
155Los Angeles ChargersArizona Cardinals15.6
156Los Angeles ChargersCarolina Panthers15.6
157Carolina PanthersWashington Commanders15.6
158Los Angeles RamsSeattle Seahawks15.5
159Detroit LionsArizona Cardinals15.4
160Los Angeles ChargersLos Angeles Rams15.4
161Los Angeles ChargersWashington Commanders15.4
162Tennessee TitansLos Angeles Rams15.4
163Los Angeles RamsCarolina Panthers15.4
164Detroit LionsLos Angeles Rams15.1
165Los Angeles RamsArizona Cardinals15.1

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images

More by Clayton Gray

 

Underdog ADP Movement: How Best-Ball ADP Is Changing

Clayton Gray

Underdog ADP: A look at the current state of Best-Ball ADP and how it is moving.

05/18/25 Read More
 

2025 NFL Schedule Grid

Clayton Gray

The NFL schedule in grid format.

05/15/25 Read More
 

2025 NFL Schedule: Prime Time Games

Clayton Gray

A team-by-team look at the 2025 NFL prime time games.

05/14/25 Read More
 

2025 NFL Schedule: Bye Weeks

Clayton Gray

Each team's bye week for the 2025 NFL schedule.

05/14/25 Read More
 

2025 NFL Strength of Schedule By Team

Clayton Gray

The team-by-team strength of schedule for the 2025 NFL season.

05/14/25 Read More
 

Underdog ADP Movement: How Best-Ball ADP Is Changing

Clayton Gray

Underdog ADP: A look at the current state of Best-Ball ADP and how it is moving.

05/11/25 Read More