Is This Real? Week 2

Our Jordan McNamara looks at surprising outcomes to see if they will continue.

Jordan McNamara's Is This Real? Week 2 Jordan McNamara Published 09/11/2024

After one week, it is important to consider what is real and what is not sustainable for fantasy production.

Isaiah Likely's Hot Start

Isaiah Likely burst onto the scene in week one with a career game, with 12 targets for 9 receptions, 111 receiving yards, and a touchdown. 

This led the team in targets, receptions, and yards while significantly outplaying teammate Mark Andrews, who finished with 2 targets, 2 receptions, and 14 yards. 

What does this mean for the future? 

Mark Andrews was still the leader in routes (38) ahead of Likely (35), but Likely was targeted on his routes much more frequently (34%) than Andrews (5%). 

This is a hot start for Likely, but he still plays behind Andrews in the offense.  Additionally, Andrews is an elite player on a per-player basis.  His career yards per route run of 2.15 is in the 99th percentile, and his career targets per route run rate of 24.5% is a 100th percentile performance. 

By comparison, Likely's career average is 1.42 yards per route run, a 77th-percentile performance, and he is targeted on 16.8% of his routes, a 61st-percentile performance.    

In preseason ADP, Andrews was TE4, while Likely was TE21.  As Adam Harstad notes, season-long production only becomes more predictive of season-long performance than ADP after week 4.  And based on their player profile, there were really strong reasons why Andrews was ranked higher than Likely in ADP.  One week of production should not dramatically shift what you think about players. 

The question is what the usage says about the future production perspective. 

The increase in Likely's snap share is the product of two factors.  First, according to Nathan Jahnke at PFF, Baltimore usage 12 personnel, with two tight ends and two wide receivers, more than 30 times in week one.  This is a marked increase over last season, when the most snaps Likely and Andrews played together in a game was 16. 

Additionally, Likely took more snaps in 11 personnel, when there is only 1 TE on the field.  When healthy last season, Andrews played 90% of the 11 personnel snaps.  In week one, Andrews played 11 of the snaps while Likely played 9 of the snaps in 11 personnel. 

While this certainly hurts Andrews' ceiling, the increase in two tight end sets make the drop in 11 personnel snap share less significant. 

Verdict: Overall, the bet should be on Andrews to be the TE1 in the offense, while Likely falls in the TE 8-16 range of the position.   Andrews' ceiling may drop, but if he falls out of the top 5 dynasty tight end valuation, he is a clear buy.  Additionally, if Likely is valued as a top 8 dynasty tight end, he is a clear sell candidate. 

Already a subscriber?

Continue reading this content with a PRO subscription.

 Jayden Reed Is a Fantasy WR1

Jayden Reed finished as WR1 in week 1, catching 4 passes for 138 yards and a touchdown while adding one carry for 33 yards and a rushing touchdown. 

Reed did this while running routes on only 74% of the team's passing dropbacks, which tied for second, with Christian Watson behind only Romeo Doubs in wide receiver route participation. 

Of his receiving production, 19.5% of his production came on yards after the catch over expectation.  Additionally, 27 of his 33 rushing yards were over expected, according to Next Gen Stats

In short, this is classic early-season, small-sample-size flukey production.  Additionally, the Green Bay Packers are expected to be without Jordan Love for some time as he recovers from a knee injury.  Malik Willis figures to start in his place and should be a substantial downgrade in passing quality and volume. 

This does not mean Week 1 is worthless.  Reed ran routes on 75% of dropbacks, something he did only four times last season when he had a season-long route participation of 61%.  Notably, Reed did this while the Green Bay receiving corps was healthy.  If there is an injury, there is room for Reed to expand his role. 

Verdict: Reed reaffirmed his excellent production has earned him more playing time.  The flukey production of week 1 is likely understood by the market, but his usage is a good indication he can expand beyond last year's production.  The news of Jordan Love's injury after this flukey production could create a buying opportunity, particularly in dynasty cost.  If Reed is valued outside of the top 20 wide receivers in dynasty, he is a buying opportunity. 

 

Photos provided by Imagn Images

More by Jordan McNamara

 

Is This Real? Week 17

Jordan McNamara

Our Jordan McNamara looks at the performances of Tennessee's backfield and Devonta Smith.

12/24/24 Read More
 

Is This Real? Week 16

Jordan McNamara

Our Jordan McNamara looks at the performances of Trey McBride and James Conner

12/18/24 Read More
 

Is This Real? Week 15

Jordan McNamara

Our Jordan McNamara looks at the performances of Kirk Cousins and C.J. Stroud

12/11/24 Read More
 

Is This Real? Week 14

Jordan McNamara

Our Jordan McNamara looks at the performances of Bucky Irving and Adam Thielen.

12/05/24 Read More
 

Is This Real? Week 13

Jordan McNamara

Our Jordan McNamara looks at the performances of Anthony Richardson and Justin Jefferson.

11/27/24 Read More
 

Is This Real? Week 12

Jordan McNamara

Our Jordan McNamara looks at the performances of Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Chase Brown.

11/20/24 Read More